Sell subscription boxes and memberships by card, renewed by choice.

Recurring billing and free trials are where card disputes and monitoring programmes start, and processors price subscription sellers to match. Railbed takes cards for prepaid plans and renewals your customers choose to pay, and settles each one to a wallet you control, where nothing is held back.

  • Renewed by choice
  • No setup fee
  • Settled sales stay yours

Press the card to run an example sale.

Settles to
Your own wallet, as USDC on Polygon
Chargebacks
Settled sales can’t be pulled back. Card disputes go to the provider
To start
An email, your website and a payout wallet. No setup fee, no monthly fee
Buyer ID checks
Providers decide. Smart Routing picks the one least likely to ask

How can a subscription box take card payments without automatic rebills?

By selling each term up front. Processors price subscription sellers as high risk because free trials and forgotten rebills turn into card disputes. Railbed takes cards for prepaid plans, such as one box, a quarter or a year, through independent, licensed card providers, and settles each payment to a wallet you control. It never stores a card or charges one automatically, so customers renew by paying again, usually from an invoice you send with reminders. It isn’t a replacement for automatic monthly billing.

Why processors treat subscription sellers as high risk

The trouble with subscriptions isn’t the product. It’s the charge a customer didn’t expect: a free trial that turned into a full price, a renewal they forgot, a cancellation that was hard to find. Those charges become disputes, disputes put a merchant into the card networks’ monitoring programmes, and processors price every subscription seller for that risk.

…reducing the number of transactions that result in disputes.

Visa, on its 2020 subscription rules
Visa

The card networks write subscription rules of their own. The Visa Core Rules require a merchant to notify the cardholder at least 7 days before a recurring charge when “A trial period, introductory offer, or promotional period is going to end”, and to “Provide a simple cancellation procedure”. Visa explained the purpose when it announced the rules: clearer information for cardholders, “reducing the number of transactions that result in disputes.” Mastercard’s standards for subscription merchants cover “a service, membership, physical product, or digital good.” A cardholder who says they withdrew permission for a recurring charge has 120 days to dispute it under Visa’s condition 13.2.

The processors go further than the networks.

What their policies say

  • Stripe. Its prohibited and restricted businesses list prohibits “Negative option marketing, negative option membership clubs, and reduced price trials with unclear or hidden pricing”.
  • Square. Its payment terms prohibit “direct marketing or subscription offers or services” and “buyers or membership clubs”.

The law adds consent rules. The Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act, 15 U.S.C. 8403, requires clear terms before billing details are taken, “express informed consent before charging”, and “simple mechanisms for a consumer to stop recurring charges”. California’s automatic renewal law was amended from 1 July 2025, and the state’s Attorney General says a customer who enrolled online “must be able to cancel it online at will”. The FTC’s 2024 click-to-cancel rule was vacated by a federal appeals court in July 2025, and the FTC restarted that rulemaking in March 2026.

Every rebill a customer doesn’t recognise is a dispute waiting to happen, and every dispute counts toward Visa’s monitoring threshold, which fell to 1.5% of transactions in April 2026.

How Railbed changes the subscription model

Railbed doesn’t charge cards automatically. That’s a real limit, and it’s worth being clear about: there are no rebills, no card on file and no free trial that converts into a charge. Instead, customers buy a plan up front, for a box, a month, a quarter or a year, and renew by paying again when it ends. Each payment settles as USDC straight to a wallet you control, and once it settles it’s yours.

What goes wrong todayWith Railbed
A forgotten rebill becomes a disputeNothing is charged automatically. Every payment is one the customer chose
A free trial converts into a charge the customer didn’t expectNo card is stored, so nothing converts. Sell a paid first box instead
A reserve held against future refundsNothing is held back from your sales
A dispute months later comes out of your balanceSettled payments can’t be pulled back from your wallet. Disputes go to the card provider that charged the card
Subscription offers are on the processor’s prohibited listNo underwriting and no application to pass

This suits businesses that already sell in prepaid terms, and businesses that want out of the dispute cycle. It isn’t a drop-in replacement for automatic monthly billing; if you need that, Railbed isn’t it.

Prepaid plans and renewals with Railbed

Each card provider has a minimum amount, so plans of about $10 or more give buyers the widest choice of providers. If your box is coffee, meals or books, the pages for coffee shops and cafés, meal prep and bookstores cover those trades.

What one forgotten rebill costs

Take a $35 box on automatic billing. The customer forgot the renewal, sees the charge and calls their bank, not you. At a conventional processor the $35 comes back out of your balance. Stripe’s dispute documentation says it “debits your Stripe balance for the disputed amount plus a dispute fee”, and that outside Mexico “the fee for receiving a dispute is non-refundable.” In the United States that fee is $15, and since June 2025 contesting a dispute costs another $15, returned only if you win.

The box has already shipped. So one forgotten $35 rebill can cost you the $35, the box, the postage and $15 to $30 in fees, and it counts toward the monitoring threshold in the figures above.

A prepaid plan removes the charge the customer didn’t expect, because there isn’t one. It doesn’t remove every dispute. A customer can still dispute a payment they chose to make, for a box that never came or wasn’t what the page showed. With Railbed that dispute goes to the card provider that charged the card, and a settled payment can’t be pulled back from your wallet. The customer is still yours to look after.

What a prepaid plan looks like

A prepaid plan is a fixed number of boxes paid for in one payment. It ends by itself. The prices below are examples, not Railbed’s:

PlanExample pricePaidBoxes you oweThe customer’s next decision
One box$35Today1Next month
Three months$99Today3In three months
Six months$189Today6In six months
A year$360Today12In a year

A year plan puts twelve boxes of revenue in your wallet before you’ve packed the second one. That money is owed boxes, so keep enough of it to pack and post them, and to refund a customer who leaves early if your terms allow it.

A pricing table holds up to four plans, which fits the four rows above. A label such as “per month” on a plan is only a label: it never schedules a charge.

Which way to sell fits your business

What you sellHow to sell itWhat to know
A monthly box with a few plan lengthsA pricing table on your site, with the plan you’d recommend markedThe customer picks a term, pays once and gets that many boxes
A box sold from a Shopify or WooCommerce storePrepaid plans listed as ordinary products, paid on Railbed’s checkoutCarts with Shopify’s own subscription items stay on Shopify’s checkout
A membership or paid communityA checkout page, with access given when the signed payment.paid webhook arrivesAccess ends when the term does, unless the member pays again
Renewals for customers you already haveAn invoice for the next term, sent as the current one endsThe customer pays by card from the invoice or lets the plan end
Gift plansThe same pricing table, bought by the giverAsk for the recipient’s delivery address at checkout
Corporate or bulk ordersAn invoice with a line for each plan, a due date and termsAn invoice total can be up to 100,000.00

How a customer buys a plan

  1. The customer picks a plan on your pricing table and enters an email.

  2. Smart Routing sends them to the card provider most likely to approve their card.

  3. They pay on the provider’s page, which decides whether to ask them to confirm who they are; Smart Routing tries the providers least likely to ask first.

  4. The provider buys USDC with the payment and it’s forwarded to your wallet on Polygon. Railbed checks the amount and the wallet before it marks the payment Paid.

  5. Your shop or platform starts the plan from the verified payment, and you send a renewal invoice when it’s due.

Try the whole flow in Test mode before you take a real order. No card is charged.

Renewals the customer chooses

Without a stored card, a renewal is a second sale. That is the whole point of the model, and it changes the work you do near the end of each plan.

Two limits are worth planning for. Railbed sends up to 200 invoice emails a day for a business, so a seller with more renewals than that due on one day should spread the due dates or send the invoice’s own link from its own email tool. And a customer who has to choose may choose not to. Prepaid renewals keep the customers who want the next box, and lose the ones who would have paid only because they forgot.

Subscription rules and cases, 2019 to 2026

Regulators and card networks have spent years on the same problem this page starts with: the charge the customer didn’t expect.

  1. Apr 2019

    UrthBox, a snack box seller, settles FTC charges over a “free” trial of its snack boxes that enrolled customers in a six-month subscription, and agrees to pay $100,000.

  2. Sep 2019

    Visa publishes its rules for free trials and introductory offers, written to cut the disputes those offers cause.

  3. Oct 2024

    The FTC announces its final click-to-cancel rule for subscriptions and memberships.

  4. 1 Jul 2025

    California’s amended automatic renewal law takes effect.

  5. 8 Jul 2025

    A federal appeals court vacates the FTC’s click-to-cancel rule, days before businesses had to comply with all of it.

  6. Aug 2025

    HelloFresh, a meal kit company, is ordered to pay $7.5 million to settle a lawsuit alleging it broke California’s automatic renewal law.

  7. Sep 2025

    Amazon agrees to pay $2.5 billion, a $1 billion civil penalty and $1.5 billion in refunds, to settle the FTC’s case over Prime enrolment and cancellation.

  8. Mar 2026

    The FTC asks for public comment on writing a new negative option rule, with comments due by 13 April 2026.

  9. May 2026

    Shutterstock agrees to pay $35 million to settle FTC allegations about charges without informed consent and subscriptions that were hard to cancel.

Is the click-to-cancel rule in force?

No. The FTC finished the rule in October 2024, and its last parts were due to apply from 14 July 2025. On 8 July 2025 the Eighth Circuit threw it out. In the FTC’s own account, the court vacated the rule “holding that the Commission had failed to conduct the preliminary regulatory analysis required under section 22 of the FTC Act”. In March 2026 the FTC asked the public whether and how to start again. On 20 November 2026 its rule page showed no new final rule.

That doesn’t mean the pressure is off. The same notice says “The Commission continues to receive thousands of complaints each year regarding negative option marketing”, and that the rate has risen “from at least 33 per day in late 2020 to more than 90 per day in 2025.” The law the rule was built on, ROSCA, never went away, and three of the cases in the timeline came after the court’s decision. The order against Shutterstock requires it to “maintain simple cancellation mechanisms for negative option features”.

The states have their own laws. California’s Attorney General lists what its amended law asks for, including:

  • “A business must get a consumer’s express affirmative consent to auto-renewal or continuous-service terms.”
  • For free or discounted trials lasting more than 31 days, notice “at least three days but no more than 21 days before the free or discounted period expires.”
  • “A business must give consumers an annual reminder about their auto-renewal or continuous-service plan.”

All of these rules are written around one model: a charge that happens unless the customer acts. A prepaid plan that ends unless the customer pays again is a different model. Whether any of these laws reaches your offer depends on your terms and where your customers live, which is a question for your own lawyer. This page isn’t legal advice.

Shipping what you were paid for

A prepaid plan means you hold money for boxes you haven’t sent yet. In the United States the FTC’s mail, internet or telephone order rule covers that. Its business guide says “If you make no shipment statement, you must have a reasonable basis for believing that you can ship within 30 days.” When you can’t ship on time, you have to ask the customer to agree to the delay or refund them, and the guide gives the penalty as “up to $53,088 per violation”.

The guide lists “magazine subscriptions (and similar serial deliveries), except for the first shipment” among the sales the rule doesn’t cover. Whether your later boxes count as serial deliveries is a question for your lawyer. The first box of a plan comes under the rule on either reading.

In practice:

  • Say on the plan when the first box ships, and the date an order has to arrive by to make this month’s box.
  • If a supplier lets you down, tell customers before the date passes, and offer the choice the rule describes.
  • Keep the promise you’d want kept. A customer who has paid for six boxes and received two late ones may go to their bank before they come to you.

Before you sell your first prepaid plan

  • A payout wallet. Save the Polygon wallet your payments should settle to. Use a wallet you hold the keys to, not an exchange deposit address.

  • Plans that say what they are. Name the term, the number of boxes and the price, and say plainly that the plan ends and nothing more is charged.

  • Prices that clear the minimum. Card providers have minimums, the smallest about $2, and about $10 or more gives buyers the widest choice. A $7 monthly box is better sold by the quarter.

  • A delivery address at checkout. Turn on the delivery address, and add up to five questions of your own for a size, a flavour or a dietary need.

  • A list of who is on which plan. Feed it from the signed payment.paid webhook, from Zapier or n8n, or from your shop’s own orders.

  • A renewal invoice and reminders. Write the invoice for the next term once, and turn reminders on. They are off until you do.

  • Shipping and refund terms in writing. Say when boxes ship and what happens if a customer leaves part-way through. Railbed can’t reverse a settled payment for you.

  • A Test mode run. Buy a plan yourself in Test mode and follow it through to your packing list before you go Live.

Refunds, skipped boxes and early cancellations

A prepaid plan has settled to your wallet, so a refund is something you send, not something a processor takes from you. Railbed has no control that reverses a settled payment. Return the USDC or agree another arrangement with the customer.

That makes your terms matter more, not less. Decide these before the first sale and put them where the customer sees them:

  • Leaving early. Whether a customer who stops after two boxes of six gets the other four refunded, in full or less a discount they no longer earned.
  • Skipping a month. Whether a customer can pause, and whether the plan then runs a month longer.
  • A box that goes wrong. Whether a damaged or missing box is replaced or refunded.

A customer who can get their money back from you quickly has little reason to ask their bank. If your shop runs on WooCommerce, recording a refund there doesn’t send money. It is a note in your shop, and the money still has to leave your wallet.

Running Railbed beside automatic billing

Nothing about Railbed is exclusive, and you may want both models for a while.

Any automatic billing you keep elsewhere still has to follow the card rules and the laws above. Using Railbed for part of your sales doesn’t change that.

Fees and getting paid

There’s no setup fee and no monthly fee. Fees come out of the USDC that arrives: the card provider’s own fee and spread, a 1% network fee, and the Railbed fee, from 0.9%, shown in your dashboard and locked when the customer starts paying. Prices can be in USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, AUD, INR or SEK.

Settlement is almost always USDC on Polygon, a dollar stablecoin, to your own wallet. To reach your bank, send it to an exchange or off-ramp and withdraw (how). Refunds for unshipped boxes are yours to honour from your own wallet, because Railbed can’t reverse a settled payment.

Your terms stay yours

Using Railbed doesn’t make an offer lawful. Clear terms, honest pricing and a simple way to stop renewal reminders are yours to provide, and any automatic billing you run elsewhere still has to follow ROSCA, state law and the card rules. The acceptable use policy holds only the limits the law places on Railbed.

When Railbed is not the right fit

Words worth knowing

Negative option
An offer where the seller treats a customer’s silence as agreement to be charged. Free trials that convert and automatic renewals are both negative options.
Continuity
The trade’s word for billing a stored card on a schedule until the customer cancels. Railbed doesn’t do it.
Rebill
An automatic charge to a stored card for the next period. One the customer doesn’t recognise is a dispute waiting to happen.
Prepaid plan
A fixed number of boxes or months paid for in one payment. It ends by itself, and nothing more is charged unless the customer pays again.
Renewal invoice
An invoice for the next term, sent as the current one ends. The customer pays it by card or lets the plan end.
ROSCA
The Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act, the US law that requires clear terms, informed consent and a simple way to stop recurring charges sold online.
Click to cancel
The name given to the FTC’s 2024 rule on cancelling subscriptions. A federal appeals court vacated it in July 2025, before all of it applied.
Automatic renewal law
A state law on plans that renew by themselves. California’s, amended from 1 July 2025, covers consent, reminders and cancelling online.
Dispute
A cardholder’s challenge to a charge through their bank, also called a chargeback. At a conventional processor the amount comes back out of your balance.
Monitoring programme
A card network’s watch on merchants whose fraud and disputes pass a set share of sales. Visa’s threshold has been 1.5% since April 2026.

Questions

Why do processors treat subscription boxes as high risk?

Because of the charge a customer didn’t expect. Trials that convert and renewals people forgot become disputes, disputes count toward the card networks’ monitoring thresholds, and processors price or refuse subscription sellers for that risk. Two processors’ published terms are quoted near the top of this page.

Is the FTC’s click-to-cancel rule in force?

No. A federal appeals court vacated it on 8 July 2025, and in March 2026 the FTC asked for public comment on starting a new rule. On 20 November 2026 no new rule had been published. ROSCA and state automatic renewal laws still apply to automatic billing.

How do customers renew without a stored card?

They pay again. As a plan ends, you send an invoice for the next term with a due date, and reminders if you’ve turned them on. The customer pays it by card, or doesn’t, and the plan ends.

Do automatic renewal laws apply to a prepaid plan?

Those laws are written for charges that repeat unless the customer cancels, and a prepaid plan charges once and ends. Whether a law reaches your offer depends on your terms and your customers’ location, so ask your own lawyer. Clear terms and honest pricing are yours to provide either way.

What’s the smallest plan I can sell?

Each card provider has its own minimum, the smallest about $2. Plans of about $10 or more give buyers the widest choice of providers, so a low-priced box is better sold as a quarter or a year.

Can a customer cancel a prepaid plan part-way through?

That’s for your terms to say. Railbed can’t reverse a settled payment, so if you refund the unused boxes, you send the money yourself. Put the rule on the plan before the customer buys.

Can I sell gift subscriptions?

Yes. A gift is a prepaid plan bought by someone else. Ask for the recipient’s delivery address at checkout, and nothing renews unless someone chooses to pay for another term.

Can I keep my current subscription billing and add Railbed?

Yes. Nothing about Railbed is exclusive. One way to start is to keep automatic monthly billing where you have it and sell prepaid terms and gifts through Railbed. On Shopify, carts with subscription items stay on Shopify’s own checkout.

How fast does the money arrive?

Usually within minutes of the customer paying. Each payment settles as USDC to your own wallet, and Railbed never holds it.

Does Railbed support recurring billing?

No. Railbed never charges a card automatically and doesn’t store cards. Customers buy prepaid plans and renew by paying again, usually from a renewal invoice you send with reminders.

Can I offer a free trial?

Not one that converts into a charge, because Railbed can’t charge a card later. Offer a paid first box or a short paid plan instead, then send a renewal when it ends.

Why would a subscription business choose prepaid plans?

Prepaid plans bring money in up front, and they remove the forgotten rebill, the unexpected charge that Visa’s subscription rules were written to reduce. Every Railbed payment is one the customer chose to make.

What happens if a customer disputes a payment?

The dispute goes to the card provider that charged the card, and a settled payment can’t be pulled back out of your wallet. Railbed charges no chargeback fee.

Do customers need crypto?

No. They pay by card on a normal checkout. Only you need a wallet.

Can Railbed freeze my money?

No. Every payment settles straight to a wallet you control, so there’s no balance with Railbed to hold. Railbed can stop new payments on an account only when the law requires it, and it can never touch USDC already in your wallet.

Sources

  1. Visa: Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules, 24 October 2026, checked 20 November 2026
  2. Visa: Subscription policy FAQ, 26 September 2019, checked 20 November 2026
  3. Mastercard: Subscription, recurring payments and negative option billing merchants, updated November 2022, checked 20 November 2026
  4. Visa: Visa Acquirer Monitoring Program fact sheet, thresholds from 1 April 2026, checked 20 November 2026
  5. Stripe: Prohibited and restricted businesses, last updated 22 September 2026, checked 20 November 2026
  6. Square: US payment terms, 6 November 2026, checked 20 November 2026
  7. 15 U.S.C. 8403, Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act, Cornell Law School, checked 20 November 2026
  8. California Attorney General: Consumer alert on the automatic renewal law, 4 September 2025, checked 20 November 2026
  9. FTC: Negative option rule, checked 20 November 2026
  10. Federal Register: Rule concerning the use of prenotification negative option plans, advance notice of proposed rulemaking, 13 March 2026, checked 20 November 2026
  11. FTC: UrthBox settles FTC charges related to compensated online reviews and “free trial” offer, 3 April 2019, checked 20 November 2026
  12. Los Angeles County District Attorney: HelloFresh to pay $7.5 million for deceptive subscription practices, 18 August 2025, checked 20 November 2026
  13. FTC: FTC secures historic $2.5 billion settlement against Amazon, 25 September 2025, checked 20 November 2026
  14. FTC: Shutterstock to pay $35 million to settle FTC allegations over illegal subscription and cancellation practices, 13 May 2026, checked 20 November 2026
  15. FTC: Business guide to the FTC’s mail, internet, or telephone order merchandise rule, checked 20 November 2026
  16. Stripe: How disputes work, checked 20 November 2026
  17. Stripe: June 2025 pricing updates for disputes, checked 20 November 2026

Last updated .

PaidThree boxes, prepaid, settled to your wallet$105.00

Pack the next box.
Renewals are their choice.

Set up in under a minute. Your first payment can settle today.

  • Renewed by choice
  • No setup fee
  • Settled sales stay yours

Moving a lot of volume? Talk to our team